The future for OPC UA, TSN, and Industrial Ethernet in Industry 4.0

This article provides some background information about the question: what role will OPC UA, TSN, and classic Industrial Ethernet systems play in the future?


By Volker E. Goller, Analog Devices                                              Download PDF version of this article


OPC UA forms a universal application interface through its address space, whereas TSN adds real-time capabilities to standard Ethernet and enables gigabit data speeds. Thus, it makes sense to combine the two technologies via a publish/subscribe (pub/sub) model, but there are also other possibilities for industrial communications in the context of Industry 4.0.

To clarify the role of OPC UA, I would like to quote Stefan Hoppe, vice president of the OPC Foundation: “OPC UA is not a protocol; it is an information model.” By that, he means that OPC UA is first and foremost an information model. Of course, there is also a protocol for connecting clients and servers, but its strength lies in the address space, and this is what makes OPC UA a universal application interface. The flexibility allows existing user interfaces - the profiles of the industrial Ethernet protocols - to be mapped to OPC UA. Hence, now nearly every profile in an Industrial Ethernet protocol is either already represented in the OPC UA address space or work is underway to accomplish this. OPC UA has not yet specified these profiles (I/O, drive, safety, etc), but this will probably change. In the framework of Industry 4.0, it is being viewed as a lingua franca that holds great promise for the future.

In contrast, TSN is an extension of IEEE-802.1 Ethernet with an entire series of new possibilities aimed at making the Ethernet more deterministic and real-time capable. Because TSN-capable hardware will be expected from numerous manufacturers in the future, it can also be viewed as the democratization of real-time communications. Nearly every protocol could gain real-time capabilities with TSN. Against this backdrop, a pub/sub working group was established with the aim of specifying a real-time capable transport protocol for OPC UA with the help of TSN. This would make OPC UA real-time capable and a potential alternative to Industrial Ethernet protocols. For the level above the classic PLC, it would be very welcome in light of the fact that controllers from different manufacturers would be able to interact in real-time with OPC UA. TSN can also give OPC UA a guaranteed bandwidth in the network, and hence greater robustness than is currently possible.

However, pub/sub is not the only way to marry OPC UA and real-time. Efforts are also being made to develop an OPC UA model for DDS - a widespread, proven real-time protocol. This would enable operation of distributed systems with DDS/TSN and use of OPC UA as an application interface. It remains to be seen what will happen. But classic Industrial Ethernet protocols are not going to disappear. Some will continue to exist in a different form (as profiles or profile families in OPC UA) and others will be based on TSN in the future. Classic fieldbuses will be superseded by Ethernet.

To state it clearly once again, TSN does not automatically imply OPC UA. They are two completely independent technologies. OPC UA can play a major role in networking of controllers (controller-to-controller). Pub/sub with TSN is advantageous here; whether it can also play a role at the field level has yet to be proven, because OPC UA is not a small stack, at least not if you want to make use of all the advantages. I would say that all user organizations are responding to the TSN opportunity. It promises a greater selection of hardware, especially infrastructure components, as well as a way of achieving higher speeds - that is, 1 Gbps and higher. Ultimately, we will see Profinet TSN, as well as EtherNet/IP over TSN and OPC UA pub/sub.

To get below a cycle time of 250µs at 100 Mbps, the established Industrial Ethernet protocols are going to have to make significant modifications to standard Ethernet. The IEEE is not well disposed towards nonstandard approaches such as the summation frame protocols on which, for example, EtherCATand even Sercos are based. It is not likely that these extensions will be incorporated into the TSN standard. TSN will reach the limit defined by the IEEE for 250µs at 100 Mbps - at least as long as true parallel operation with standard TCP/IP applications has to work. For shorter cycle times, the road to 1 Gbps is open. 1 Gbps (and above) is a logical progression of today’s networking. Will it take the place of 100 Mbps? Not everywhere, but 1 Gbps allows for new applications and enables the performance bottlenecks that occur today with data-intensive applications to be overcome.

Safety normally makes use of the black channel principle. It is defined above the actual communications protocols. However, reliability of the communications channel is a factor in safety calculations. TSN is not going to become less reliable than today’s systems are. TSN adds deterministic real time to standard Ethernet. In many cases, different protocols coexist in one and the same cable. TSN enables robust parallel existence of real-time and best-effort TCP/IP in one cable. But TSN is not a new Industrial Ethernet protocol. It is a unified extension that adds real-time capabilities to standard Ethernet. The advantages have already been laid out: hardware availability, unified infrastructure, and speed-independent definition. Scalable, standardized hardware and infrastructure promise cost reductions and unified know-how.


Related


Give Your Product a Voice with Alexa

Join us for a deep dive into the system architecture for voice-enabled products with Alexa Built-In. Device makers can use the Alexa Voice Service (AVS) to add conversational AI to a variety of produc...

The two big traps of code coverage

Code coverage is important, and improving coverage is a worthy goal. But simply chasing the percentage is not nearly so valuable as writing stable, maintainable, meaningful tests. By Arthur Hick...

Securing the smart and connected home

With the Internet of Things and Smart Home technologies, more and more devices are becoming connected and therefore can potentially become entry points for attackers to break into the system to steal,...

Accurate and fast power integrity measurements

Increasing demands on power distribution networks have resulted in smaller DC rails, as well as a proliferation of rails that ensure clean power reaches the pins of integrated circuits. Measuring r...

 


Arduino CEO Fabio Violante on their migration upwards in engineering

In this video Arduino CEO Fabio Violante talks about their ambitious migration upwards in engineering solutions and products with Alix Paultre in Tegernsee, Germany. Arduino, long known for their deve...


Silicon Lab CEO Tyson Tuttle talks about their wireless IoT portfolio

In this video Silicon Lab's Tyson Tuttle talks to Alix Paultre about their new wireless IoT portfolio. Wireless Xpress provides a configuration-based development environment, with certified Blueto...


Keysight's Joachim Peerlings talks about the new UXR series Oscilloscope

In this video Keysight's Joachim Peerlings talks about the new UXR series Oscilloscope with Alix Paultre at their launch event in Munich. The Infiniium UXR-Series of oscilloscopes has models rangi...


BrainChip explains their new Neuromorphic System-on-Chip

In this video, Bob Beachler of BrainChip talks to Alix Paultre about their latest single-chip neural network technology.  Spiking neural networks (SNNs) are inherently lower power than traditiona...


Vincotech – EMPOWERING YOUR IDEAS

In this video the Vincotech team walks us through the most important topics displayed on their booth at PCIM Europe 2018. It also explains why Vincotech is First in SiC Modules. Being very flexible in...


Microchip talks about their latest secure microcontroller

Microchip's new SAM L10 and SAM L11 families of 32-bit microcontrollers (MCUs) address the growing need for security in Internet of Things (IoT) endpoints by protecting against the increasing the ...


E-Mail Newsletters

nlsc240

Our 3 E-Mail Newsletters: EETimes/EDN Europe, Embedded News and Power Electronics News inform about the latest news in technology and products, as well as technical know-how like white papers, webinars, articles, etc.


B & S / ECE Magazine

- latest issue is online now -

November 2018

Content Highlights

Cover Story

Internet-connected displays make the industrial IoT more visible

Download now